The Power of “I Don’t Know”: A Coach’s Guide to Unlocking Growth
In coaching sessions, the phrase “I don’t know” often shows up with a sigh, a shrug, or an awkward pause. It can sound like a dead end, but it’s actually a signal of something on the horizon.
In a recent coaching conversation, a career coaching client found themselves repeatedly saying, “I don’t know.” Rather than moving past it, we stayed there. What unfolded was a powerful shift, not toward answers, but toward agency.
Below, we’ll explore how “I don’t know” can become a lever for growth in sessions, and how you can work with it in your own coaching practice.
Reframing “I Don’t Know”
Most of us are conditioned to believe that “I don’t know” equals weakness, ignorance, or unpreparedness. In reality, it’s often a signpost marking the edge of a comfort zone, the fertile space where real learning begins.
In a coaching context, “I don’t know” can signal:
A lack of clarity (ripe for exploration)
A protective defense mechanism (signaling vulnerability)
A growth edge (a place the client hasn’t had permission or time to explore)
A desire to avoid being wrong (especially in high-achieving professionals)
Coaches can reframe this phrase with clients by treating it as a cue, not a conclusion.
5 Ways to Leverage “I Don’t Know” in a Coaching Session
1. Slow Down & Normalize It
“Great. That’s a perfectly honest place to be. Let’s hang out there for a moment.”
When a client says “I don’t know,” resist the urge to fill the silence or fix it. Instead, model calm curiosity. Let the moment breathe. That pause alone can reduce performance pressure and make space for insight.
2. Ask What’s Underneath It
“If you did know, what might you guess?”
“What’s making this hard to answer?”
Sometimes “I don’t know” is a proxy for:
“I haven’t thought about this before.”
“I’m afraid to say it out loud.”
“I’m not sure what’s acceptable to want.”
Gently probing helps clients differentiate between genuine uncertainty and emotional avoidance.
3. Turn It Into a Map
“What would you need to know in order to answer that?”
This is an excellent move when coaching around transitions, career changes, or identity questions. Help the client define the information gaps. Turning ambiguity into inquiry helps them feel empowered, not stuck.
4. Use It to Surface Hidden Assumptions
“What do you think someone should know here?”
“I don’t know” often masks internalized narratives or expectations—especially for high performers who fear they should already “have it all figured out.” Help clients notice the “rules” they’ve unconsciously adopted.
5. Build the Muscle of Not-Knowing
“Let’s treat this as your lab. What experiment could you run to learn more?”
Especially in innovation, leadership, and career coaching, uncertainty is constant. Helping clients reframe “I don’t know” as an invitation to test, explore, and discover shifts their mindset from passivity to creative agency.
When “I Don’t Know” Becomes a Pattern
If you hear “I don’t know” often from a client, consider what it might be protecting:
Fear of failure or judgment
Lack of psychological safety (in or out of the session)
Habitual external validation seeking
A deeper identity shift underway
Naming the pattern, with permission, can be freeing:
“I notice we’ve hit ‘I don’t know’ a few times today. How do you usually handle uncertainty in your life or work?”
For Coaches: Practice Your Own Comfort with “I Don’t Know”
The most powerful way to model this for your clients is to embrace your own “I don’t know” moments with humility and curiosity. You don’t need to have all the answers—you need to create the space where the right questions can unfold.
“I Don’t Know” is a Beginning, Not an End
Coaching isn’t about having answers, it’s about creating a container where clients can uncover their own. When a client says “I don’t know,” smile. You’ve just arrived at the edge of something meaningful.
Future Self Design™ for Coaches
Deepen Your Craft. Expand Your Impact.
Future Self Design™ is a reflective, practice-based experience for coaches who are ready to deepen their skills, not by adding more tools, but by deepening their practice to support who their clients are becoming.
In this experience, you will:
Practice frameworks that help clients design from their future selves
Learn to work more confidently in the in-between spaces
Explore your own evolution as a coach, and what your next chapter is truly asking of you
Join a community of fellow coaches doing courageous, personal work to serve at the highest level
You’ll walk away with a clearer sense of who you are as a practitioner, what’s shifting in your presence, and how to help clients do work that actually sticks.
Join Future Self Design™
Because the coach your clients need next is already inside you—just waiting for more space to emerge.
